A Think Again Media Group publication
Space Debunk

'Oumuamua's visit

Tracking an interstellar visitor: the measured push on ‘Oumuamua

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · Space Debunk

Tracking an interstellar visitor: the measured push on ‘Oumuamua

The interstellar visitor ‘Oumuamua left a small discrepancy in a remarkably demanding set of position measurements. An orbit calculated using gravity alone did not follow all the observations. Marco Micheli and colleagues reported the extra acceleration in 2018, after combining ground-based images with Hubble observations. Material escaping from a warming surface offered a physically viable explanation, provided the object's thermal properties resembled those of comets. The detected departure from the gravity-only path and the proposed source of the push were different parts of the investigation.

The observing record was substantial despite the short encounter. Micheli's team analyzed 177 ground-based positions and 30 positions from Hubble, with coverage extending to January 2, 2018. Their gravity model included the Sun, eight planets, the Moon, Pluto, the 16 largest main-belt bodies and relativistic effects. Systematic offsets remained. Adding an acceleration directed radially away from the Sun produced a satisfactory description, with strength decreasing as the interstellar visitor moved farther from it. The team reported a detection at 30 standard deviations. That statistical result concerns the fitted acceleration, rather than a chemical identification of escaping gas.

NASA's June 27, 2018 release described the observational puzzle through the research team's statements. Comets commonly release gas and dust as solar heating affects their surfaces, and that outflow can alter their motion. ‘Oumuamua showed no visible signs of the expected activity. The researchers proposed that an outflow carrying little detectable dust might still provide a small push. Karen Meech suggested that fine surface grains could have been eroded during the long interstellar journey. This was a possible history for the interstellar visitor, offered to explain an absence in the images rather than an event directly witnessed by a telescope.

The object's appearance needs the same care. NASA's accompanying explanation states that even the largest telescopes recorded a point of light. Changes in brightness suggested an extreme shape and a complicated tumbling motion, but there was no resolved close-up photograph. Exact dimensions depended on interpretation of that light. The interstellar visitor came within roughly a quarter of the Earth–Sun distance of the Sun, yet its surface details remained unknown. A long, thin illustration is therefore a model of possible appearance. It is separate from the measured track across the sky and the changing brightness from which shape was inferred.

Radiation pressure has also been explored under unusual assumptions. In a 2019 paper, Amaya Moro-Martín proposed an exceptionally porous aggregate of icy dust that could have enough area relative to its mass for sunlight to supply the acceleration. Micheli's rejection concerned bodies with more conventional properties. The aggregate proposal changes those properties; it does not establish that this was ‘Oumuamua's structure.

In 2023, Jennifer Bergner and Darryl Seligman proposed a specific natural reservoir for the escaping material. Their paper modeled an initially water-rich icy body exposed to energetic particles during its journey between stars. Laboratory work cited in their study showed that irradiation can produce molecular hydrogen within water ice, leaving some hydrogen trapped in the surrounding material. As the interstellar visitor warmed near the Sun, rearrangement of that icy structure could release the trapped gas. Their calculation connected a history of irradiation to a later source of recoil, without requiring the whole object to be a block of pure hydrogen ice.

That proposal also addressed why ordinary gas searches might miss the activity. Bergner and Seligman noted that molecular hydrogen would not have been detectable in the optical, infrared and centimeter-wavelength observations used to constrain other gases. Their model sought to fit the measured acceleration while respecting those nondetections. The claimed gas supply and release rate came from calculations informed by experiments on ice. No instrument sampled ‘Oumuamua's interior or directly measured its trapped hydrogen. For this interstellar visitor, the paper supplied a testable physical explanation consistent with several constraints, rather than a newly obtained composition measurement.

The hydrogen model drew a quantitative challenge. Thiem Hoang and Abraham Loeb argued in a 2023 paper that evaporating hydrogen would cool the body, an effect they said the earlier thermal calculation omitted. Their one-dimensional models, using two thermal conductivities, reduced the volume warm enough to release hydrogen by factors of nine and five. Under those assumptions, they concluded that too little hydrogen could escape to supply the required acceleration. The disagreement concerns the thermal budget and available material. It does not erase the positional measurements or make either calculation a direct observation of the interior.

The thermal disagreement affects both the gas reservoir and its ability to supply a push. Hoang and Loeb calculated that including hydrogen evaporation lowered the modeled surface temperature by a factor of nine and the thermal speed of escaping hydrogen by a factor of three. Their challenge to the proposed mechanism therefore goes beyond whether hydrogen can form in irradiated ice. A release of gas must also carry sufficient momentum under the temperatures reached during the encounter. The interstellar visitor's trajectory constrains that required push even when the body's internal inventory remains unmeasured.

NASA's 2018 summary also records the limits of the encounter: a hyperbolic trajectory carrying the object out of the solar system, an unidentified home system, and observations ending as it faded beyond detection. Those limits leave a finite body of images for continued analysis. The most concrete legacy is the combination of an unbound path, unusual brightness changes, missing visible activity and a small additional acceleration. Each physical model has to satisfy those constraints together, including the ability to push an object without producing a coma bright enough for the telescopes to detect.

The Question

Which mechanism is cited as a plausible explanation for 'Oumuamua's extra acceleration?

Show the answer

The Answer

The evidence favors a natural comet or asteroid. 'Oumuamua's extra acceleration has plausible explanations, including radiation pressure or material released as an object warms near the Sun.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Space Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.