A Think Again Media Group publication
Space Debunk

Polaris and Earth's changing orientation

Axial precession: the changing pole behind a dated sky map

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Space Debunk

Axial precession: the changing pole behind a dated sky map

Axial precession enters the calculations used to compare planetary observations with predicted positions. In a report dated June 15, 1967, JPL astronomer Jay Lieske addressed a problem with comparing planetary observations and predicted positions: both sets of coordinates had to refer to the same reference system. His Technical Report 32-1044 developed mathematical expressions for precession and their dependence on astronomical constants. The slow movement of Earth's rotational axis was something that had to enter a calculation, even when an observing campaign lasted far less than a complete cycle.

Lieske's introduction identifies the ingredients behind the lengthy expressions: the mean obliquity at 1900.0, the rate of general precession in longitude at that epoch, and planetary masses. His worked framework also distinguishes coordinates referred to a fixed equator and equinox, such as 1950.0, from coordinates referred to those of the observation date. The transformation changes the coordinate reference. It does not require the observed planet to have physically jumped between the two positions. Later sections develop the expressions for an arbitrary starting epoch, allowing the same machinery to connect different reference dates.

The physical cause of axial precession comes from Earth's shape and rotation. Earth bulges at the equator, and the gravitational attractions of the Moon and Sun act on that bulge. NASA's StarChild explanation compares the resulting change in direction with the axis of a spinning top after a nudge. The axis traces a cone rather than maintaining one orientation forever. A complete circuit takes approximately 26,000 years. Daily rotation continues throughout that slow change: the planet can keep spinning while the direction of its spin axis gradually moves.

Polaris occupies its present role because the northern end of that axis currently points almost toward it. A different part of the stellar background lies in that direction at other stages of the cycle. StarChild places Thuban, also called Alpha Draconis, near the northern pole around 3000 BC and identifies Vega as a future northern pole star roughly 13,000 years from now. Those are widely separated stages of the same geometrical motion. They do not describe stars taking turns moving into a permanent, externally fixed north-pointing line. The line defined by Earth's spin is changing.

Direction and tilt describe different aspects of the axis. NASA's explanation of orbital cycles separates axial precession from obliquity, the size of Earth's tilt. The present tilt is about 23.4 degrees; over the last million years it has ranged between 22.1 and 24.5 degrees, in a cycle of roughly 41,000 years. A diagram of a steadily tilted axis sweeping around a cone therefore isolates one motion while simplifying another. The tilt itself also varies. Combining the two changes into a single undifferentiated wobble would lose the different timescales and geometrical quantities involved.

Axial precession also shifts the relationship between seasons and Earth's position along its orbit. NASA notes that the closest approach to the Sun currently occurs during Northern Hemisphere winter and Southern Hemisphere summer. In roughly 13,000 years, the seasonal relationship will be reversed. The calendar remains tied to the seasons, so that change does not put Northern Hemisphere winter in July. A separate motion, apsidal precession, changes the orientation of the orbital ellipse. NASA gives about 23,000 years for the combined precession cycle relevant to seasonal orbital alignment, rather than the approximately 26,000-year axial circuit.

The coordinate grid carries the same moving geometry into measurements. In NASA's Basics of Space Flight, the celestial sphere has its poles and equatorial plane aligned with Earth's. Declination functions as celestial latitude: the equator is zero degrees, while the poles are plus and minus 90 degrees. Right ascension supplies the corresponding longitude, with its zero point at the vernal equinox. These definitions tie an equator-based sky position to Earth's orientation. The manual separately describes the International Celestial Reference System, whose axis directions are fixed in space, and the transformations connecting coordinate systems.

An epoch pins the equator-based reference to a specified time. The manual explains J2000.0 in terms of the mean equator and equinox of 2000 and contrasts it with the earlier B1950.0 reference. Mean positions exclude the smaller nodding contribution called nutation. Superimposed on the long precession cycle, that motion has an important component with a period of 18.6 years and an amplitude of 9.2 arcseconds. A precise pointing calculation consequently needs more than a broad circular path sketched across thousands of years.

The stars bring another independent movement into the measurement. NASA distinguishes proper motion, a star's own motion, from shifts associated with Earth's orientation. Its navigation example requires an observer to remove Earth's motions when determining a spacecraft's speed or a distant star's motion. Axial precession belongs on that correction side of the calculation. Polaris can serve as a useful present-day direction marker while the numerical reference used for a demanding observation remains explicitly dated. The same rotating Earth that supplies a convenient northern landmark also supplies a reference frame whose orientation must be tracked.

The Question

What slow motion of Earth changes which star lies near the north celestial pole?

Show the answer

The Answer

Axial precession. Earth's rotational axis gradually changes orientation, shifting the celestial poles against the stars.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Space Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.