A Think Again Media Group publication
Space Debunk

The unexpected relay inside a 1960 space experiment

Echo satellite: the enormous balloon between two ground stations

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Space Debunk

Echo satellite: the enormous balloon between two ground stations

The Echo satellite carried a communications experiment into orbit on August 12, 1960, but the experiment's signal amplifiers remained on Earth. A large, aluminum-coated balloon reflected radio transmissions between distant ground stations. The spacecraft did not receive a telephone signal, amplify it electronically, and transmit a stronger version back down. NASA described the system as passive communication, a distinction that separated its giant reflective sphere from the active repeater satellites developed alongside it.

The successful spacecraft was called Echo 1A, often shortened in historical accounts to Echo 1 or Echo I. NASA's 2010 account placed its launch after an unsuccessful attempt with the original Echo I. The balloon measured 100 feet, or about 30 meters, across and was made from Mylar polyester.

An Echo satellite prototype preserved another scale in the project's development. NASA's account of a May 1, 1960, skin stress test described a model only 12 feet in diameter. That size followed the ceiling height of the Langley model shop. NASA identified the orbital version as a reflector for telephone, radio, and television experiments over transcontinental and intercontinental distances.

The ground stations contained substantial hardware of their own. NASA's history of the August 1960 experiment described a 26-meter antenna built at Goldstone, California, several miles from the Pioneer antenna. Its transmitter operated in the S-band at 2.39 gigahertz. Another antenna at Holmdel, New Jersey, received transmissions. A prerecorded message from President Dwight Eisenhower traveled from California to New Jersey after the balloon entered orbit. The historical description located the sophisticated transmitter at Goldstone, rather than inside the balloon passing overhead.

An archival photograph records the Echo satellite's first pass over Goldstone in the early morning of August 12, 1960. NASA's caption identifies the long streak of the satellite, shorter star trails, and movement of the antenna. The photograph was later included in a NASA/JPL gallery released in 2016. Its caption described the balloon as a structure roughly ten stories high, linking the long trail in the exposure with the dimensions of the object that made it.

NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory described its role as sending and receiving signals through two 85-foot, or 26-meter, antennas at Goldstone. The balloon concept originated with an engineer at Langley Research Center, while Goddard Space Flight Center managed the project. Goldstone later became part of the Deep Space Network. The division of work in this account placed the balloon, project management, and ground communications equipment in different institutional hands. Its nickname, satelloon, joined the project's spacecraft status to its unusual balloon construction.

The Echo satellite expanded after reaching orbit. NASA's description of the design attributed that expansion to residual air within the balloon. The enlarged surface then reflected radio transmissions from one ground station toward another. The same agency account noted that the satellites attracted public interest because they were visible to the unaided eye during overhead passes. Their visibility accompanied the engineering experiments, but the communication service depended on radio reflection, rather than on the visible streak recorded in photographs.

The passive arrangement also belonged to a specific institutional setting. Historian David J. Whalen described congressional concern about duplication between NASA and the Department of Defense. NASA initially concentrated on mirror-like passive experiments, while the defense program handled active repeaters that amplified received signals aboard the satellite. Whalen traced this division alongside interest from AT&T's Bell Telephone Laboratories. John R. Pierce had evaluated both orbiting mirrors and repeaters in a 1954 speech and a 1955 publication, before Echo's launch.

The alternatives soon developed in parallel. By the middle of 1961, NASA had contracted with RCA for Relay, AT&T was building Telstar for a NASA launch, and Hughes was developing Syncom under a NASA contract. Whalen's history recorded successful operation of two satellites from each of those three families by 1964. These programs embodied different choices of orbit and equipment from the large passive balloon. Echo's historical role lay in demonstrating a working reflection link during that period of competing experimental designs.

Whalen traced the commercial outcome through the Communications Satellite Corporation, formed following the Communications Satellite Act of 1962. COMSAT began with capitalization of $200 million and selected a geosynchronous system for its first operational satellites. Agreements establishing the International Telecommunications Satellite Organization were signed on August 20, 1964. Early Bird launched on April 6, 1965, after communications ground stations had been established in the United Kingdom, France, Germany, Italy, Brazil, and Japan. By the end of 1965 it had provided 150 telephone half-circuits and 80 hours of television service. NASA credited Echo with research on atmospheric density, solar pressure, and lightweight structures as well as communications. The balloon that had helped establish the earlier experimental links reentered the atmosphere on May 24, 1968.

True or False?

Echo 1 relayed telephone calls by amplifying the communication signals aboard the satellite.

Show the answer

The Record

Echo 1 was a passive reflector: communication signals bounced off its aluminum-coated balloon. The transmitting and receiving equipment for those links remained at ground stations.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Space Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.