Cosmic rays measured by balloons, satellites, and gamma-ray signatures
Cosmic rays carry matter through space at extraordinary energies. Protons, the nuclei of hydrogen atoms, make up the largest share; helium nuclei and heavier nuclei contribute the rest of the dominant nuclear population. CERN gives an approximate composition of 89 percent protons, 10 percent helium nuclei, and 1 percent heavier nuclei, extending to uranium. Those proportions describe particles with mass and charge, despite the familiar name. The radiation arriving from distant space can be investigated by separating its nuclear species and measuring their energies.
The atmosphere complicates that measurement. Incoming cosmic rays collide with atomic nuclei in the upper atmosphere and generate secondary particles, including pions. Charged pions can decay into muons, which penetrate through the atmosphere and even below ground because they do not interact strongly with matter. CERN estimates that about one muon each second crosses a volume the size of a person's head. Thus a detector at ground level often encounters products of an earlier collision. Its immediate surroundings are different from the particle population entering the atmosphere from space.
The balloon-borne Cosmic Ray Energetics and Mass experiment, CREAM, carried its detectors high above most of that atmosphere. Y. S. Yoon and colleagues reported proton and helium measurements from a 42-day Antarctic flight during the 2004–2005 southern summer. The average altitude was about 38.5 kilometers, leaving an average atmospheric overburden of roughly 3.9 grams per square centimeter. The instrument distinguished individual elements through their charge, reporting charge resolutions of about 0.15 elementary-charge units for protons and 0.2 for helium nuclei. The flight conditions and the charge separation were part of the measurement, rather than incidental travel details.
CREAM found that proton and helium energy distributions behaved differently. Its reported proton spectrum covered 2.5 to 250 teraelectronvolts, while the helium measurement covered 630 gigaelectronvolts to 63 teraelectronvolts per nucleon. Across the shared range from 2.5 to 63 teraelectronvolts per nucleon, the proton-to-helium abundance ratio was 9.1, with an uncertainty of 0.5. This was smaller than earlier measurements at much lower energies. The result illustrates why one approximate percentage cannot describe cosmic rays at every energy: the relative populations change across the measured spectrum.
The satellite-borne PAMELA experiment provided another direct comparison. O. Adriani and colleagues reported precision proton and helium spectra in 2011 over a rigidity range from 1 gigavolt to 1.2 teravolts. They found that the two species had different spectral shapes and that a single power law did not describe them well. Their result concerned the distribution of arriving particles, rather than a photograph of the source that accelerated them. Protons and helium were abundant enough for the experiment to examine that distribution with considerable precision.
The PAMELA team interpreted the observed structures as a challenge to the prevailing combination of supernova-remnant acceleration and subsequent diffusive propagation through the galaxy. More complex acceleration and transport processes were needed to explain the measurements. This did not remove protons and helium from the particle population. It constrained how those particles gained energy and reached the detector. The distinction matters experimentally: identifying an incoming nucleus and reconstructing the astrophysical journey that produced its observed energy require different kinds of evidence, even when they start with the same data.
Gamma rays offered a complementary way to locate proton acceleration. In 2013, the Fermi Large Area Telescope collaboration reported a characteristic feature in the gamma-ray spectra of the supernova remnants IC 443 and W44. Accelerated protons striking interstellar material can produce neutral pions, which then decay into gamma rays. High-energy electrons can also generate gamma rays through other processes, so the presence of gamma radiation alone was insufficient to identify the parent particles. The team detected the specific spectral signature expected from pion decay, linking the emission to accelerated protons in those remnants.
That observation connected two particle populations without treating them as identical. Fermi detected the gamma rays emitted after proton collisions, while experiments such as CREAM and PAMELA measured charged particles arriving at their instruments. The Fermi study presented the pion feature as direct evidence of proton acceleration in supernova remnants. Its result identified a physical production mechanism at particular sources. The emitted gamma rays provided information about the charged cosmic rays there; they did not make ordinary starlight, radio waves, or gamma photons the main material counted in the incoming nuclear population.
Conditions near the Sun further change what reaches Earth. NOAA's Space Weather Prediction Center describes galactic cosmic-ray nuclei as fully ionized, with their electrons stripped away, making them responsive to magnetic fields. Solar magnetic activity and the solar wind particularly restrict lower-energy arrivals near solar maximum. Access becomes easier near solar minimum, and the galactic cosmic-ray maximum therefore occurs near the quieter part of the roughly 11-year solar cycle. Their spectrum and composition generally change slowly, unlike abrupt solar bursts. Measurements near Earth consequently reflect both the distant sources and the intervening magnetic environment through which the particles have traveled.
- CERN, Cosmic rays: particles from outer space — home.cern
- Y. S. Yoon and colleagues, Cosmic-Ray Proton and Helium Spectra from the First CREAM Flight, 2011 — arxiv.org
- O. Adriani and colleagues, PAMELA Measurements of Cosmic-ray Proton and Helium Spectra, 2011 — arxiv.org
- Fermi-LAT Collaboration, Detection of the Characteristic Pion-Decay Signature in Supernova Remnants, 2013 — arxiv.org
- NOAA Space Weather Prediction Center, Galactic Cosmic Rays — www.spaceweather.gov