A Think Again Media Group publication
Space Debunk

The Mars-as-big-as-the-Moon rumor

Mars close approach: what Hubble actually recorded in 2003

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Space Debunk

Mars close approach: what Hubble actually recorded in 2003

The Mars close approach of August 2003 produced an extraordinary telescope opportunity. Hubble photographed the planet at a separation of about 55.8 million kilometers, capturing recognizable volcanoes, canyons and a shrinking polar cap. The view available without a telescope remained a bright point. The difference matters because a large, detailed planetary portrait can conceal the enormous optical enlargement involved in making it. Mars supplied the target; Hubble supplied the close-up.

The original August 27 image has a precise observing history. Hubble's Wide Field and Planetary Camera 2 collected a series of exposures between 5:35 and 6:20 a.m. EDT, within minutes of the nearest encounter. Its caption gives the distance as 55,757,930 kilometers. The natural-color composite shows Olympus Mons near the center, the dark canyon system Valles Marineris below and to the right, and the southern polar cap near the bottom. Those identifiable features belong to a dated instrumental observation, with an instrument and exposure sequence attached.

The cap itself records the season. Southern summer meant continuous sunlight at the pole, and the visible ice was shrinking. NASA identified orange streaks over it as signs of dust activity. Although the cap contained both carbon dioxide ice and water ice, only the carbon dioxide ice was visible; water ice lay underneath. Faint clouds also hovered over Arsia Mons. Even this unusually sharp view therefore contained limits: a bright patch could reveal an exposed layer while concealing another beneath it.

The favorable Mars close approach arose from two different orbital periods and two imperfectly circular tracks. NASA's contemporary observing material gave Earth a 365-day year and Mars a 687-day year. Earth catches up roughly every 26 months, bringing Mars opposite the Sun in our sky. The distance varies because Mars follows a markedly elliptical orbit. In 2003, Mars was near its closest region to the Sun while Earth was near its more distant region. The combination narrowed the gap without producing a Moon-sized planet overhead.

The observing program was correspondingly ambitious. Jim Bell's team planned 25 Hubble orbits around the encounter, anticipating surface detail roughly 5–10 kilometers across. Four instruments would examine the planet through different methods and wavelengths. Ultraviolet spectra could constrain surface properties and atmospheric ozone; near-infrared observations would search for water-bearing minerals. Another program would follow the atmosphere before and after opposition. These were stated observing goals. The large photographic disk resulted from a telescope designed to resolve fine angular detail at interplanetary distances.

A separate NASA imaging release from June 2001 supplies a useful scale comparison. For that encounter, the predicted apparent diameter was 20.8 arcseconds at a closest separation of about 67 million kilometers. Its accompanying explanation compared a 20-arcsecond object with a dime seen from 190 meters away, or with a 40-kilometer crater on the Moon. A whole planet can occupy a very small angle. Greater brightness around a Mars close approach does not turn that small angle into the breadth of the full Moon.

The 2001 release also distinguished physical configurations from actual photographs. The illustrated Mars views were simulations of the planet as seen from Mars Global Surveyor. Its dates separated opposition on June 13–14 from closest approach on June 21, while equinox fell on June 17–18. Earth-based viewing remained difficult because of the small disk, low contrast and turbulence in our atmosphere. A diagram, an orbital simulation and an observation can describe the same encounter while supplying different kinds of evidence about its appearance.

Hubble's October 28, 2005 observation exposed another piece of the imaging machinery. The Advanced Camera for Surveys' High Resolution Channel sampled about 0.025 arcsecond per pixel, in images roughly 1,000 pixels square. Its finer sampling favored compact planetary targets. A fixed occulting mask, intended to suppress bright light, covered a small part of Mars in one corner. The obstruction belonged to the camera. It was not a dark region of the Martian surface or a change in the planet's outline.

For the public color composite, the missing patch was filled using nearby areas of similar color and texture. NASA explicitly distinguished that cosmetic treatment from the handling of data published in scientific papers. The mask example makes the Mars close approach tangible as an observing operation: a narrow camera field, a finely sampled disk and a documented correction for an instrumental obstruction. A richly detailed finished portrait carries those choices with it, even when the hardware itself sits outside the displayed frame.

The circulating Moon-sized claim left its own contemporary trace. On June 28, 2005, Emily Lakdawalla reproduced an email promising a giant Mars and placed Bruce Betts's observing guidance alongside it. Betts described a roughly 20-arcsecond disk for the coming encounter, about 5 arcseconds smaller than in 2003. He also separated the naked-eye point from the polar cap and surface markings accessible in a small telescope.

True or False?

At a close approach, Mars can look as large as the full Moon to the naked eye.

Show the answer

The Record

False. Even at close approach, Mars remains a point of light to unaided eyes.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Space Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.