A Think Again Media Group publication
Space Debunk

Can Hubble see the Apollo landers on the Moon?

Hubble resolution: a lunar landscape at two different distances

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Space Debunk

Hubble resolution: a lunar landscape at two different distances

Hubble resolution can be checked against an actual observation of the Apollo 17 region. NASA's image catalogue identifies an exposure taken on August 16, 2005, with the telescope's Advanced Camera for Surveys. It covers the Taurus-Littrow valley, where astronauts walked and drove in December 1972, and marks the landing region with a plus sign. The catalogue describes ultraviolet and visible imaging, identifies the camera channel, and links the observation to proposal 10719. This is a documented view of the landscape, with a specified instrument and date, rather than a photograph of the lander's hardware.

NASA's design description supplies the optical scale. Hubble's primary mirror measures 2.4 meters across. Light reflects from that mirror to a smaller secondary mirror, then back through a hole in the primary toward the cameras and spectrographs. The agency quotes angular resolution of about 0.05 arcsecond. That number describes a tiny angle between distinguishable details. It is different from the diameter of the mirror, the physical size of the target, or the amount by which a finished image has been enlarged on a screen.

The lunar distance converts that angle into a ground scale. The Apollo 17 catalogue gives an Earth-Moon distance of about 384,403 kilometers. Using that distance with the quoted 0.05-arcsecond angle gives approximately 93 meters by the small-angle calculation, conventionally rounded to about 90 meters. NASA's JSC Almanac lists the Apollo lunar module as 9.4 meters across its legs, well below that rounded lunar scale. Hubble resolution expressed in meters therefore depends on the target distance. The approximately 90-meter figure is a useful lunar scale, rather than a universal minimum object size applicable wherever the telescope points. It also represents an approximate optical capability, not a guarantee that every surface feature of that width will stand out.

Brightness and shape introduce a further distinction. NASA says Hubble's detectors are sensitive enough to detect a four-watt night-light on the Moon from Earth. Detecting its light would not mean separating the lamp's edges, housing, and internal parts. Those are measurements of spatial detail. The same observatory can register a point of light while leaving the source's physical dimensions unresolved. This distinction explains how impressive sensitivity can coexist with a lunar image that cannot display the structure of an Apollo lander. More collected light and finer resolved shape describe different capabilities.

The limit also involves the behavior of light. Diffraction spreads light from a point source within a telescope's optical system. Its scale depends on both aperture and wavelength, so a single rounded resolution number does not describe every observing band identically. Hubble operates across ultraviolet, visible, and near-infrared wavelengths. Its location above Earth's atmosphere removes the blurring associated with shifting air, as NASA's observatory description explains, but it does not give the telescope unlimited resolving power. Hubble resolution remains finite even when the atmospheric interference that troubles ground observations is absent.

A much closer observation produced a different record in 2011. NASA's September 8 astronomy image describes an Apollo 17 view taken by Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter during a modified orbit that brought it about 22 kilometers above some Apollo sites. Its labels identify Challenger's descent stage, the parked lunar rover, and the Apollo Lunar Surface Experiments Package. Rover tracks and the astronauts' foot trails are visible too. These are trails across the surface, rather than a catalogue of individually resolved boot impressions. The difference from the 2005 landscape follows a dramatic change in observing distance.

The orbiter also supplied a comparison spanning the Apollo 12 landing. NASA's July 9, 2013 release places an LRO image beside an earlier Lunar Orbiter 3 view of Surveyor crater. Both views cover the same part of Oceanus Procellarum. The earlier spacecraft's principal objective was to identify safe landing areas for Surveyor and Apollo missions. Surveyor 3 had landed there on April 20, 1967; Apollo 12 later set down about 155 meters from it on November 19, 1969. The newer image reveals Intrepid, the Surveyor spacecraft, and astronaut tracks. NASA says the displayed LRO image was stretched to better match the earlier view. Both missions gathered images to characterize possible landing terrain. The paired observations bracket the arrival of Apollo 12: one preceded the landing, while the other includes its equipment and surface disturbance. They locate changes within a particular patch of lunar terrain.

Those changes include a larger pattern surrounding the equipment. NASA attributes increased reflectivity around the Apollo 12 site to the descent engine's exhaust altering the soil. Immediately beneath and near Intrepid, disturbed and roughened ground appears darker; farther out, the affected surface appears brighter. The broad altered area and the small hardware are distinct features of the same site. Hubble resolution at lunar distance, the orbiter's close pass, and the surface's changing reflectivity each enter the comparison. A labeled landscape, a resolved spacecraft, and a broad patch of disturbed soil are different observational results.

True or False?

At the Moon's distance, Hubble's resolution limit is about 90 meters across.

Show the answer

The Record

At that distance, Hubble's resolution tops out at resolving objects no smaller than about 90 meters across. Which means we can't see the astronauts' boot prints — and we also can't even see the Apollo lunar landers, which NASA lists as about 9.4 meters across their extended legs. The interesting limit is resolution: the telescope cannot read details that small on the Moon. Source: Scientific American, "Why Can't the Hubble Space Telescope See Astronauts on the Moon?"

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Space Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.