Aurora colors: the 2024 storm and the limits of night vision
Aurora colors can be present in the light even when a person sees a pale, almost white glow. NOAA's explanation ties that appearance to night vision: the eye can detect brightness before it distinguishes color. A camera may register a display, and its colors, while human vision struggles. The pale impression can therefore be real without making the atmospheric emission itself uniformly white. The May 2024 storm left a particularly useful set of observations of this difference.
NASA's contemporaneous record follows the event from the Sun to Earth. Its Solar Dynamics Observatory recorded 82 notable flares between May 3 and May 9, mainly from two active regions. Multiple coronal mass ejections followed, bunching into waves that began reaching Earth on May 10. The resulting storm reached G5, the highest category on the geomagnetic storm scale. Auroras appeared unusually far from the poles, including the southern United States and northern India. Their geographic reach made this an exceptional opportunity to collect observations.
Those observations arrived through different channels. NASA reported thousands of submissions to its Aurorasaurus citizen-science project and emphasized the value of photographs, including phone images. It also encouraged reports of places where nothing was seen. A non-sighting supplied information about visibility rather than an empty contribution. The solar images in the same release were different again: extreme-ultraviolet observations displayed in assigned blue and gold. Their colors represented an instrument's wavelength selection, rather than a naked-eye view of the Sun.
Hisashi Hayakawa and colleagues assembled a separate research record of the storm. Their 2024 study combined solar observations, satellite measurements, ground-based neutron monitors and auroral reports. It placed the arrival of a shock at 17:05 UT on May 10 and reported a disturbance storm time index minimum of −412 nanoteslas at 02:00 UT on May 11. Those measurements document the magnetic disturbance independently of how colorful any particular photograph appeared. The study ranked the event as the sixth-largest storm in that index since 1957.
The team reconstructed the equatorward boundary of the visual auroral oval at 29.8 degrees invariant latitude. It explicitly compared naked-eye and camera visibility and cautioned about their differences. That distinction belongs inside a reconstruction of the display's reach: a photographic detection and a visual sighting are different observations. The study's quantified boundary concerned the visual oval. A collection of images can extend knowledge of a storm while requiring care about which detection method produced each location.
The emitted aurora colors arise from physical processes high in the atmosphere. Energetic electrons follow Earth's magnetic field and transfer energy to atmospheric atoms and molecules. When those excited particles release photons, different transitions produce different wavelengths. NOAA identifies the familiar green oxygen emission at 557.7 nanometers, another oxygen state producing red, and nitrogen contributing additional colors. The atmospheric mixture supplies the light's spectrum before an eye or a camera detects it.
Altitude changes which emissions survive. NOAA describes green oxygen light across roughly 120–400 kilometers. The red-emitting state lasts much longer and is more easily quenched by collisions in denser air before releasing its photon. Nitrogen can produce a purple lower border with little delay after excitation. These differences can give an aurora layers and differently moving edges. A pale appearance at ground level does not remove those distinct emitting species or their different response times.
Aurora colors meet a second filter in the eye. In their 2017 review of dim-light color vision, Almut Kelber, Carola Yovanovich and Peter Olsson describe three spectral types of cones supporting human color vision in bright conditions. At much lower light levels, vision relies on a single type of rod receptor and loses reliable color discrimination. Between those regimes, rods and cones both contribute. Aurora colors therefore depend on the light reaching the retina and on which visual pathways can use that light.
The transition is gradual. The same review describes decreasing saturation and shifts in perceived hue and brightness as illumination falls. Rod sensitivity peaks near 500 nanometers, while the combined daylight sensitivity peaks nearer 555 nanometers. This change helps explain why a dim scene's brightness relationships can differ from its daylight appearance. It also prevents a simple rule that every aurora must look equally colorful: low-light perception changes with intensity and adaptation, even before a camera's different sensitivity enters the comparison.
An original laboratory study published in 2025 examined another consequence of rod vision. Pablo Barrionuevo, Alexander Schütz and Karl Gegenfurtner asked participants to compare gray patches in patterned surrounds, then used a four-primary display to stimulate rods or cones selectively at the same adaptation level. Rod-driven vision increased the tendency for a patch's brightness to shift toward that of its surroundings. A control using smoothed patterns indicated that poorer spatial resolution alone did not explain the effect. These were controlled measurements of perceived brightness, rather than auroral observations.
- Hayakawa et al., The Solar and Geomagnetic Storms in May 2024: A Flash Data Report (2024), original multi-instrument and visual-record analysis — arxiv.org
- NOAA/NWS Space Weather Prediction Center, Aurora Tutorial, emission colors and naked-eye versus camera visibility — www.spaceweather.gov
- NASA, How NASA Tracked the Most Intense Solar Storm in Decades, May 16, 2024, solar observations and citizen-science records — science.nasa.gov
- Kelber, Yovanovich and Olsson, Thresholds and noise limitations of colour vision in dim light (2017), vision research review — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Barrionuevo, Schütz and Gegenfurtner, Increased brightness assimilation in rod vision (2025), original human visual-perception experiments — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov