A Think Again Media Group publication
Space Debunk

Did telescope viewers really see canals built on Mars?

Mars canals: how astronomers drew waterways that never existed

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Space Debunk

Mars canals: how astronomers drew waterways that never existed

In 1877 Mars made a close approach to Earth, and the Italian astronomer Giovanni Schiaparelli spent it mapping the planet. The features he drew looked to him like geographical straits, so he called them "canali." English translators rendered the word as "canals," which suggested artificial waterways rather than natural channels. That one word helped start one of the longest-running misreadings in astronomy: the Mars canals, said to have been built by Martians.

The planet makes Mars canals easy to imagine. Royal Museums Greenwich notes that "even with large telescopes it is very difficult to see detail" on Mars, and that "many experienced observers were deceived into thinking that they had glimpsed features, such as the infamous canals." A small reddish disk with faint dark markings is a hard thing to draw accurately, and the eye wants to connect the dots.

Percival Lowell turned a drawing habit into a theory. A Google Arts and Culture exhibit on the Mars canals describes him as a North American businessman and orientalist who became a committed advocate. In 1894 he founded an observatory in Flagstaff, Arizona, on a hill now known as Mars Hill. Lowell added more than a hundred features to Schiaparelli's list and argued that a Martian civilization had built the canals to move water from the polar ice caps and fight the drying of the planet. His 1897 map showed an engineered world covered in an intricate network of lines. Astronomers discredited the ideas, yet newspapers and magazines carried them into public imagination.

The same exhibit makes a telling point: no one claimed to see a well-defined pattern of canals directly through a telescope, "not even Lowell." The network took shape in sketches and drawings, as observers tried to make sense of what they saw. Lowell's observatory site in Flagstaff was chosen for its air, since he wanted what astronomers call superior seeing. The LibreTexts astronomy text says he tested many sites before settling on a lumber town of about 1,000 people, then built on a hill 300 feet above it.

The Mars canals idea spread into popular culture. LibreTexts describes the period as "Mars Mania," driven by books and articles that promoted the canals and claimed seasonal growth of Martian vegetation. In 1898 H. G. Wells published The War of the Worlds, which added to the excitement. The text also quotes Earl Slipher, a Lowell astronomer whose book The Photographic Story of Mars set photographs beside drawings of the canals, and who wrote as late as 1962 that photographs had recorded "traces of so many of the canals and oases" and should remove all doubt of their reality.

The first serious crack came from an observer who had once agreed with Lowell. The Google Arts and Culture exhibit says Eugène Antoniadi had supported Lowell for years. In 1909 and 1910 he observed Mars with a 33-inch telescope at the Meudon Observatory in France, a large instrument. The exhibit adds that astronomers found atmospheric stability decisive, and that larger telescopes could magnify atmospheric turbulence and make viewing harder rather than easier.

What Antoniadi saw instead was detail. In moments of good visibility during 1909 and 1910 he found that the supposed canals were really many discrete features. It concludes that "it became clear that the canals were nothing more than an optical illusion." The Mars canals, in other words, had been assembled from small markings that the eye joined together.

Spacecraft could settle whether any hidden pattern remained. NASA describes Mariner 4 as the first spacecraft to take close-up photographs of another planet. After an eight-month voyage, its television camera took 22 pictures in July 1965, covering about one percent of Mars. The image NASA highlights was transmitted on July 15 from 7,829 miles away. The pictures were stored on a four-track tape recorder and took four days to send to Earth. They showed lunar-type impact craters, including one 94 miles across, and some craters were touched with frost during the Martian evening. LibreTexts summarizes the result plainly: when spacecraft first explored Mars in 1965, Mariner 4 showed no canals at all.

The current explanation is that observers' eyes connected real features into lines that did not exist, much like connecting the dots. Royal Museums Greenwich adds that almost all that is known about the surface of Mars and its atmosphere has been discovered by space probes. The canals never ran across the planet. They ran across paper, drawn by people squinting at a small disk through unsteady air and looking for a pattern.

True or False?

The canals reported by early telescopic observers were real artificial structures on Mars.

Show the answer

The Record

False. Seeing detail on Mars is very difficult even with large telescopes, and many experienced observers were deceived into thinking they had glimpsed features such as the infamous canals. Nobody built them. They were an optical illusion that spacecraft pictures ended.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Space Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.