Sound transmission: a moving bell, a quiet jar, and signals from space
Sound transmission has a particularly clear test in NASA's 1998 Suited for Spacewalking activity guide. Its first vacuum experiment puts an electric doorbell inside a bell jar, with wires passing through a sealed stopper. The instructions call for evacuating the jar, operating the bell, and gradually admitting air while holding the button. In the evacuated condition, the clapper remains visibly in motion even though the ringing cannot be heard. The device is still operating. Changing the material surrounding it changes whether its vibration reaches the surrounding room as audible sound.
The visible clapper is an essential part of that demonstration. A quiet bell alone could have stopped because its electrical supply failed. Here, motion remains available as a separate observation while the air supply changes. The guide links the result directly to the use of two-way radios in spacesuits: sound does not pass through a vacuum. The mechanical disturbance needs a material medium. Removing the air removes that path, rather than automatically changing the vibration into a different kind of signal that continues across the empty gap.
A radio provides a different transport mechanism. NASA's description of radio waves identifies them as electromagnetic radiation and explains that a receiver converts the arriving waves into mechanical vibrations in a speaker. Audible sound is produced at that receiving end. Sound transmission through the air near the speaker and transmission of the radio signal are separate stages. This is why hearing a transmitted voice from a spacecraft does not require the original pressure disturbance to have traveled across interplanetary space. The signal crosses space electromagnetically, and the receiving equipment generates a new local sound wave.
Mars offers a useful recorded case because its atmosphere supplies matter even though that atmosphere is extremely thin. NASA's April 1, 2022 release presents sounds from Perseverance, including a dust-removal tool, the Ingenuity helicopter, and the laser striking rocks. The accompanying study mainly used SuperCam microphone measurements from the mission's first 216 Martian days. These were acoustic observations made in the Martian environment. A microphone on a rover inside an atmosphere is a different observing arrangement from an imagined microphone surrounded by a perfect vacuum.
The measurements exposed properties of that medium. NASA reports that lower-pitched sounds traveled at about 240 meters per second on Mars, while higher-pitched sounds traveled at about 250 meters per second. It attributes the unusual behavior to the thin, cold, mostly carbon dioxide atmosphere. Higher-pitched tones also attenuated strongly. Sound transmission therefore depends on more than whether matter is present at all: its composition and conditions influence propagation. The quietness of the recordings gave the researchers information about the atmosphere, rather than establishing that no atmosphere or acoustic path existed.
Voyager's much-publicized interstellar recording involved another instrument entirely. NASA's 2013 description identifies the Plasma Wave Science instrument on Voyager 1 and the data played by its principal investigator, Don Gurnett. The instrument sensed electron waves in ionized gas surrounding the spacecraft. It was not a microphone listening for ordinary airborne noise. The waves occurred at audio frequencies, so the data could be passed through a loudspeaker. Their pitch provided information about the density of the surrounding plasma. The audible playback represented an instrumental measurement translated into a form people could hear.
The same release distinguishes the measurements on opposite sides of the heliosphere. It gives typical plasma-wave frequencies near 300 hertz inside and between 2 and 3 kilohertz outside, where the gas was denser. It describes observed outbursts in October-November 2012 and April-May 2013, excited by solar activity. The crucial medium was ionized gas. Calling the playback the sounds of interstellar space did not make the measured region empty, nor did it turn electron plasma oscillations into ordinary acoustic sound transmission through a vacuum. NASA explicitly distinguishes the instrument's electron-wave detection from sound detection.
A further example comes from the Perseus galaxy cluster. NASA's June 2022 sonification release describes pressure waves that create ripples in the cluster's hot gas. That gas supplies a medium for sound transmission. Chandra's X-ray data allow the structures to be studied at a distance; the published audible version extracts signals in radial directions and shifts them upward by 57 to 58 octaves. The sound in the playback is therefore far above the original frequency. The gas-borne disturbance and the production of an audible data product are both part of the measurement history.
The companion M87 sonification uses a different mapping. It scans an image assembled from radio, optical, and X-ray observations, assigning those three wavelength ranges to low, middle, and high audible tones. Brightness controls loudness. That product translates electromagnetic observations into audio; it does not claim that a microphone recorded those tones beside the black hole. The two published sonifications illustrate why the instrument and conversion method matter. A pressure wave in gas, an electron oscillation in plasma, and an image assigned musical pitches can all produce a playable file while representing different physical measurements.
- Gregory L. Vogt and Jane A. George, NASA, Suited for Spacewalking, March 1998, printed page 92, Vacuum Experiment 1 — ntrs.nasa.gov
- NASA, Radio Waves, Tour of the Electromagnetic Spectrum — science.nasa.gov
- NASA/JPL, What Sounds Captured by Perseverance Rover Reveal About Mars, April 1, 2022 — www.nasa.gov
- Tony Phillips, NASA, The Sounds of Interstellar Space, 2013: Voyager plasma-wave measurements — science.nasa.gov
- NASA Universe of Learning, Data Sonifications: Black Holes, June 14, 2022: Perseus and M87 processing descriptions — science.nasa.gov